| 2023 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Eltham 18.18 (126) def St Mary's 6.12 (48) | 78 |
| Elimination Final | South Morang 19.13 (127) def Watsonia 6.12 (48) | 79 |
| First Semi Final | St Mary's 18.12 (120) def South Morang 15.9 (99) | 21 |
| Second Semi Final | Diamond Creek 7.4 (46) def by Eltham 10.11 (71) | 25 |
| Preliminary Final | Diamond Creek 12.10 (82) def St Mary's 4.11 (35) | 47 |
| Grand Final | Eltham 12.13 (85) def Diamond Creek 6.8 (44) | 41 |
| 2022 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Banyule 11.8 (74) def Lower Plenty 10.9 (69) | 5 |
| Elimination Final | Diamond Creek 11.13 (79) def Thomastown 9.3 (57) | 22 |
| First Semi Final | Lower Plenty 11.9 (75) def by Diamond Creek 15.6 (96) | 21 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 10.9 (69) def by Banyule 11.12 (78) | 9 |
| Preliminary Final | Eltham 7.13 (55) def Diamond Creek 6.10 (46) | 9 |
| Grand Final | Banyule 10.17 (77) def Eltham 7.10 (52) | 25 |
| 2019 | | |
| First Semi Final | Eltham 8.15 (63) def Thomastown 6.8 (44) | 19 |
| Second Semi Final | Banyule 11.9 (75) def Whittlesea 10.8 (68) | 7 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 13.6 (84) def Eltham 8.8 (56) | 28 |
| Grand Final | Banyule 6.11 (47) def by Whittlesea 10.14 (74) | 27 |
| 2018 | | |
| First Semi Final | Banyule 10.18 (78) def Thomastown 8.13 (61) | 17 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 6.8 (44) def Lower Plenty 4.6 (30) | 14 |
| Preliminary Final | Lower Plenty 10.10 (70) def Banyule 7.8 (50) | 20 |
| Grand Final | Eltham 2.10 (22) def by Lower Plenty 3.10 (28) | 6 |
| 2017 | | |
| First Semi Final | Fitzroy Stars 8.11 (59) def by Lower Plenty 17.10 (112) | 53 |
| Second Semi Final | North Heidelberg 19.12 (126) def Diamond Creek 9.2 (56) | 70 |
| Preliminary Final | Diamond Creek 10.11 (71) def Lower Plenty 9.10 (64) | 7 |
| Grand Final | North Heidelberg 19.15 (129) def Diamond Creek 7.10 (52) | 77 |
| 2016 | | |
| First Semi Final | Fitzroy Stars 13.6 (84) def by Diamond Creek 13.7 (85) | 1 |
| Second Semi Final | North Heidelberg 14.10 (94) def Hurstbridge 11.11 (77) | 17 |
| Preliminary Final | Hurstbridge 11.9 (75) def Diamond Creek 8.5 (53) | 22 |
| Grand Final | North Heidelberg 11.6 (72) def by Hurstbridge 12.11 (83) | 11 |
| 2015 | | |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 14.2 (86) def Fitzroy Stars 11.5 (71) | 15 |
| Second Semi Final | Lalor 14.14 (98) def Hurstbridge 9.6 (60) | 38 |
| Preliminary Final | Hurstbridge 14.15 (99) def by Whittlesea 20.14 (134) | 35 |
| Grand Final | Lalor 14.10 (94) def by Whittlesea 14.13 (97) | 3 |
| 2014 | | |
| First Semi Final | Mernda 17.12 (114) def Lalor 13.8 (86) | 28 |
| Second Semi Final | North Heidelberg 16.17 (113) def by Fitzroy Stars 21.13 (139) | 26 |
| Preliminary Final | North Heidelberg 19.14 (128) def Mernda 11.7 (73) | 55 |
| Grand Final | Fitzroy Stars 11.12 (78) def by North Heidelberg 16.18 (114) | 36 |
| 2013 | | |
| First Semi Final | North Heidelberg 11.12 (78) def Diamond Creek 9.18 (72) | 6 |
| Second Semi Final | Whittlesea 14.12 (96) def by Fitzroy Stars 22.15 (147) | 51 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 17.10 (112) def North Heidelberg 13.11 (89) | 23 |
| Grand Final | Fitzroy Stars 14.13 (97) def by Whittlesea 17.14 (116) | 19 |
| 2012 | | |
| First Semi Final | Diamond Creek 9.18 (72) def by Fitzroy Stars 15.12 (102) | 30 |
| Second Semi Final | Epping 14.13 (97) def North Heidelberg 10.8 (68) | 29 |
| Preliminary Final | North Heidelberg 17.14 (116) def Fitzroy Stars 14.9 (93) | 23 |
| Grand Final | Epping 15.21 (111) def North Heidelberg 17.5 (107) | 4 |
| 2011 | | |
| First Semi Final | Lalor 7.10 (52) def by Diamond Creek 13.9 (87) | 35 |
| Second Semi Final | Lower Plenty 20.16 (136) def Epping 16.15 (111) | 25 |
| Preliminary Final | Epping 18.19 (127) def Diamond Creek 9.15 (69) | 58 |
| Grand Final | Lower Plenty 12.14 (86) def Epping 4.10 (34) | 52 |
| 2010 | | |
| First Semi Final | Diamond Creek 19.21 (135) def Epping 10.6 (66) | 69 |
| Second Semi Final | Whittlesea 11.7 (73) def Lower Plenty 7.15 (57) | 16 |
| Preliminary Final | Lower Plenty 9.17 (71) def Diamond Creek 9.16 (70) | 1 |
| Grand Final | Whittlesea 9.17 (71) def Lower Plenty 9.3 (57) | 14 |
| 2009 | | |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 20.9 (129) def Epping 14.9 (93) | 36 |
| Second Semi Final | Macleod 12.16 (88) def Diamond Creek 7.10 (52) | 36 |
| Preliminary Final | Diamond Creek 6.12 (48) def by Whittlesea 14.14 (98) | 50 |
| Grand Final | Macleod 13.23 (101) def Whittlesea 11.11 (77) | 24 |
| 2008 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Epping 8.4 (52) def by Watsonia 7.14 (56) | 4 |
| Second Elimination Final | Macleod 12.16 (88) def Mernda 13.9 (87) | 1 |
| First Semi Final | Macleod 18.12 (120) def Watsonia 16.10 (106) | 14 |
| Second Semi Final | Whittlesea 10.11 (71) def by Thomastown 19.15 (129) | 58 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 8.11 (59) def by Macleod 16.7 (103) | 44 |
| Grand Final | Thomastown 16.10 (106) def Macleod 12.15 (87) | 19 |
| 2007 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Thomastown 10.17 (77) def by Lalor 15.20 (110) | 33 |
| Second Elimination Final | Lower Plenty 15.19 (109) def South Morang 9.13 (67) | 42 |
| First Semi Final | Lalor 19.15 (129) def Lower Plenty 14.6 (90) | 39 |
| Second Semi Final | Macleod 22.20 (152) def Whittlesea 15.16 (106) | 46 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 9.15 (69) def by Lalor 9.17 (71) | 2 |
| Grand Final | Macleod 15.13 (103) def by Lalor 18.9 (117) | 14 |
| 2006 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Whittlesea 12.11 (83) def by Thomastown 17.12 (114) | 31 |
| Second Elimination Final | Lower Plenty 12.12 (84) def by Reservoir 16.13 (109) | 25 |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir 21.8 (134) def Thomastown 14.13 (97) | 37 |
| Second Semi Final | Greensborough 19.22 (136) def Macleod 10.19 (79) | 57 |
| Preliminary Final | Macleod 21.17 (143) def Reservoir 10.9 (69) | 74 |
| Grand Final | Greensborough 23.18 (156) def Macleod 11.12 (78) | 78 |
| 2005 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Diamond Creek 18.12 (120) def Macleod 16.8 (104) | 16 |
| Second Elimination Final | South Morang 16.9 (105) def Whittlesea 9.3 (57) | 48 |
| First Semi Final | South Morang 10.14 (74) def by Diamond Creek 12.13 (85) | 11 |
| Second Semi Final | Greensborough 19.11 (125) def Mernda 17.13 (115) | 10 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 14.7 (91) def by Diamond Creek 21.14 (140) | 49 |
| Grand Final | Greensborough 9.15 (69) def by Diamond Creek 12.4 (76) | 7 |
| 2004 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Greensborough 10.9 (69) def by Panton Hill 12.9 (81) | 12 |
| Second Elimination Final | Diamond Creek 11.11 (77) def by Reservoir 19.12 (126) | 49 |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir 19.18 (132) def Panton Hill 6.9 (45) | 87 |
| Second Semi Final | Lalor 23.12 (150) def Macleod 13.12 (90) | 60 |
| Preliminary Final | Macleod 15.12 (102) def by Reservoir 17.12 (114) | 12 |
| Grand Final | Lalor 19.11 (125) def Reservoir 14.8 (92) | 33 |
| 2003 | | |
| First Elimination Final | Reservoir 13.8 (86) def by Diamond Creek 19.9 (123) | 37 |
| Second Elimination Final | Mernda 16.8 (104) def Macleod 11.5 (71) | 33 |
| First Semi Final | Mernda 4.5 (29) def by Diamond Creek 8.5 (53) | 24 |
| Second Semi Final | Lalor 8.11 (59) def Hurstbridge 2.4 (16) | 43 |
| Preliminary Final | Hurstbridge 9.8 (62) def Diamond Creek 8.3 (51) | 11 |
| Grand Final | Lalor 7.9 (51) def by Hurstbridge 20.16 (136) | 85 |
| 2002 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Whittlesea 16.18 (114) def by Mernda 18.8 (116) | 2 |
| Elimination Final | Reservoir 15.16 (106) def Macleod 9.10 (64) | 42 |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 9.21 (75) def by Reservoir 13.14 (92) | 17 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 6.10 (46) def by Mernda 16.17 (113) | 67 |
| Preliminary Final | Eltham 15.10 (100) def Reservoir 14.8 (92) | 2 |
| Grand Final | Mernda 7.17 (59) def by Eltham 12.9 (81) | 22 |
| 2001 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Hurstbridge 8.12 (60) def by Mernda 15.20 (110) | 50 |
| Elimination Final | Watsonia 10.9 (69) def by Whittlesea 19.14 (128) | 59 |
| First Semi Final | Hurstbridge 6.13 (49) def by Whittlesea 14.6 (90) | 41 |
| Second Semi Final | Lalor 12.17 (89) def Mernda 6.8 (44) | 45 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 16.15 (111) def Whittlesea 15.10 (100) | 11 |
| Grand Final | Lalor 14.9 (93) def Mernda 8.14 (62) | 31 |
| 2000 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Mernda 8.12 (60) def Whittlesea 7.6 (48) | 12 |
| Elimination Final | Eltham 13.18 (96) def Diamond Creek 12.8 (80) | 16 |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 11.14 (80) def by Eltham 14.11 (95) | 15 |
| Second Semi Final | Watsonia 15.14 (104) def Mernda 7.7 (49) | 55 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 9.16 (70) def by Eltham 23.15 (153) | 83 |
| Grand Final | Watsonia 8.6 (54) def by Eltham 12.8 (80) | 26 |
| 1999 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Eltham 14.6 (90) def Mernda 12.12 (84) | 6 |
| Elimination Final | Whittlesea 22.14 (146) def Macleod 17.12 (114) | 32 |
| First Semi Final | Mernda 10.9 (69) def by Whittlesea 10.12 (72) | 3 |
| Second Semi Final | Lower Plenty 7.12 (54) def Eltham 6.13 (49) | 5 |
| Preliminary Final | Eltham 3.8 (26) def by Whittlesea 14.13 (97) | 71 |
| Grand Final | Lower Plenty 14.18 (102) def Whittlesea 12.4 (76) | 26 |
| 1998 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Lower Plenty 13.8 (86) def by Diamond Creek 16.10 (106) | 20 |
| Elimination Final | Hurstbridge 19.15 (129) def by Macleod 22.8 (140) | 11 |
| First Semi Final | Lower Plenty 22.20 (152) def Macleod 6.13 (49) | 103 |
| Second Semi Final | Diamond Creek 14.3 (87) def Whittlesea 9.6 (60) | 27 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 8.2 (50) def by Lower Plenty 18.8 (116) | 68 |
| Grand Final | Diamond Creek 13.10 (88) def Lower Plenty 4.9 (33) | 55 |
| 1997 | | |
| Qualifying Final | Eltham 11.15 (81) def Diamond Creek 8.11 (59) | 22 |
| Elimination Final | Lower Plenty 6.6 (42) def by Reservoir-Lakeside 14.14 (98) | 56 |
| First Semi Final | Diamond Creek 13.16 (94) def Reservoir-Lakeside 8.7 (55) | 39 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 11.15 (81) def Mernda 9.13 (67) | 14 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 12.8 (80) def Diamond Creek 8.7 (55) | 25 |
| Grand Final | Eltham 13.9 (87) def Mernda 7.13 (55) | 28 |
| 1996 | | |
| Qualifying Final | West Preston 16.10 (106) def Diamond Creek 7.9 (51) | 55 |
| Elimination Final | Whittlesea 16.14 (110) def Reservoir 4.6 (30) | 70 |
| First Semi Final | Diamond Creek 13.9 (87) def by Whittlesea 14.10 (94) | 7 |
| Second Semi Final | Mernda 9.11 (65) def by West Preston 20.9 (129) | 64 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 5.6 (36) def Whittlesea 3.10 (28) | 8 |
| Grand Final | West Preston 8.6 (54) def Mernda 7.11 (53) | 1 |
| 1995 | | |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 10.10 (70) def by West Preston 15.14 (104) | 34 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 18.5 (113) def Mernda 12.9 (81) | 32 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 17.11 (113) def by West Preston 19.9 (123) | 10 |
| Grand Final | Eltham 10.14 (74) def West Preston 10.10 (70) | 4 |
| 1994 | | |
| First Semi Final | Heidelberg West 15.14 (104) def by Reservoir 20.13 (133) | 29 |
| Second Semi Final | Northcote Park 22.15 (147) def Hurstbridge 14.6 (90) | 57 |
| Preliminary Final | Hurstbridge 11.17 (83) def by Reservoir 13.14 (92) | 9 |
| Grand Final | Northcote Park 27.13 (175) def Reservoir 15.10 (100) | 75 |
| 1993 | | |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir 15.16 (106) def Northcote Park 12.13 (85) | 21 |
| Second Semi Final | West Preston 23.33 (171) def Whittlesea 10.8 (68) | 103 |
| Preliminary Final | Whittlesea 15.17 (107) def by Reservoir 21.18 (144) | 37 |
| Grand Final | West Preston 30.16 (196) def Reservoir 11.7 (73) | 123 |
| 1992 | | |
| First Semi Final | Whittlesea 1.3 (9) def by Northcote Park 6.7 (43) | 28 |
| Second Semi Final | West Preston 17.8 (110) def Diamond Creek 11.10 (76) | 34 |
| Preliminary Final | Diamond Creek 13.11 (89) def Northcote Park 8.15 (63) | 26 |
| Grand Final | West Preston 4.3 (27) def by Diamond Creek 4.6 (30) | 3 |
| 1991 | | |
| First Semi Final | West Preston 15.17 (107) by Heidelberg West 6.3 (39) | 68 |
| Second Semi Final | Mernda 17.12 (114) def Watsonia 16.15 (111) | 3 |
| Preliminary Final | Watsonia 11.6 (72) def by West Preston 22.21 (153) | 81 |
| Grand Final | Mernda 16.14 (110) def West Preston 12.9 (81) | 29 |
| 1990 | | |
| First Semi Final | Epping 15.10 (100) def Reservoir 12.5 (77) | 23 |
| Second Semi Final | West Preston 6.13 (49) def Northcote Park 4.10 (34) | 15 |
| Preliminary Final | Northcote Park 11.11 (77) def by Epping 16.19 (115) | 38 |
| Grand Final | West Preston 14.20 (104) def by Epping 17.16 (118) | 14 |
| 1989 | | |
| First Semi Final | Epping 12.12 (84) def Northcote Park 6.2 (38) | 46 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 5.10 (40) def Research 4.4 (28) | 12 |
| Preliminary Final | Research 9.6 (60) def by Epping 12.15 (87) | 27 |
| Grand Final | Eltham 18.11 (119) def Epping 17.8 (110) | 9 |
| 1988 | | |
| First Semi Final | Eltham 4.16 (40) def by West Preston 9.9 (63) | 23 |
| Second Semi Final | Epping 23.12 (150) def Mernda 12.8 (80) | 70 |
| Preliminary Final | Mernda 11.8 (74) def by West Preston 25.13 (163) | 89 |
| Grand Final | Epping 8.5 (53) def by West Preston 12.13 (85) | 32 |
| 1987 | | |
| First Semi Final | Eltham 12.9 (81) def Northcote Park 10.20 (80) | 1 |
| Second Semi Final | Reservoir-Lakeside 15.10 (100) def by Watsonia 19.11 (125) | 25 |
| Preliminary Final | Reservoir-Lakeside 14.13 (97) def Eltham 13.10 (88) | 9 |
| Grand Final | Watsonia 14.15 (99) def Reservoir-Lakeside 12.8 (80) | 19 |
| 1986 | | |
| First Semi Final | Eltham 5.15 (45) def by West Preston 6.11 (47) | 2 |
| Second Semi Final | Epping 17.14 (116) def Reservoir-Lakeside 13.11 (89) | 27 |
| Preliminary Final | Reservoir-Lakeside 17.15 (117) def West Preston 10.9 (69) | 48 |
| Grand Final | Epping 13.15 (93) def Reservoir-Lakeside 14.8 (92) | 1 |
| 1985 | | |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir-Lakeside 10.3 (63) def Eltham 8.14 (62) | 1 |
| Second Semi Final | Northcote Park 22.16 (148) def Epping 14.7 (91) | 57 |
| Preliminary Final | Epping 13.18 (96) def Reservoir-Lakeside 11.13 (79) | 17 |
| Grand Final | Northcote Park 17.12 (114) def Epping 12.12 (84) | 30 |
| 1984 | | |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir 20.19 (139) def South Morang 10.14 (74) | 65 |
| Second Semi Final | Northcote Park 27.11 (173) def West Preston 11.11 (77) | 96 |
| Preliminary Final | West Preston 12.10 (82) def by Reservoir 16.14 (110) | 28 |
| Grand Final | Northcote Park 14.16 (100) def by Reservoir 16.14 (110) | 10 |
| 1983 | | |
| First Semi Final | West Preston 5.9 (39) def by Reservoir 20.6 (126) | 87 |
| Second Semi Final | Heidelberg 15.17 (107) def Northcote Park 15.12 (102) | 5 |
| Preliminary Final | Northcote Park 16.22 (118) def Reservoir 15.14 (104) | 14 |
| Grand Final | Heidelberg 9.15 (69) def Northcote Park 8.13 (61) | 8 |
| 1982 | | |
| First Semi Final | Northcote Park 13.22 (100) def Reservoir 14.14 (98) | 2 |
| Second Semi Final | Eltham 10.15 (75) def by Macleod-Rosanna 15.11 (101) | 26 |
| Preliminary Final | Eltham 25.7 (157) def Northcote Park 13.18 (96) | 61 |
| Grand Final | Macleod-Rosanna 14.8 (92) def by Eltham 15.13 (103) | 11 |
| 1981 | | |
| First Semi Final | Reservoir 13.13 (91) def by Bundoora 18.8 (116) | 25 |
| Second Semi Final | Northcote Park 14.17 (101) def Epping 10.11 (71) | 30 |
| Preliminary Final | Epping 16.16 (112) def by Bundoora 19.14 (128) | 16 |
| Grand Final | Northcote Park 16.13 (109) def by Bundoora 17.15 (117) | 8 |
